Comparative antimicrobial activities of antiseptic mouthrinses against isogenic planktonic and biofilm forms of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans
In vitro biofilms have been developed to model the conditions in the mouth. This study compared the antimicrobial activity of three mouth rinses when tested against two different isogenic strains of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans, one of which was a clinical isolate which forms tenacious biofilms and the other a planktonic form.
Three mouth rinses and a control rinse were tested.
Essential oils (LISTERINE®)
Triclosan and PVM/MA copolymer
Amine-fluoride, stannous fluoride (Meridol®)
Control: phosphate buffered saline/PBS
Briefly, the mouth rinses were tested against planktonic bacteria by exposing a standardised number of bacteria to each rinse for 15 seconds, followed by washing with sterile PBS. The mixture was then incubated on agar plates and the number of viable colonies assessed. Likewise, biofilms were grown in tissue culture flasks and exposed to each rinse for 15 seconds. The biofilm was washed with sterile PBS, and the bacteria incubated on agar plates to allow an assessment of kill rate. Each rinse was tested six times in each assay.
All 3 mouth rinses produced statistically significant 99.99% reductions (p≤0.0001) in both planktonic strains, compared to the PBS control. Effects on the biofilm forms of the organisms were more variable.
Kill rates (% kill) for mouth rinses versus PBS control
Strain #1 (CU1000/CU1060)
Strain #2 (NJ4300/NJ4350)
Biofilm
Planktonic
Biofilm
Planktonic
Control (PBS)
-
-
-
-
Essential oils (LISTERINE®)
98.2
>99.9
96.5
>99.9
Amine, stannous fluoride
20.0
>99.9
5.5
>99.9
Triclosan PVM/MA copolymer
8.0
>99.9
3.3
>99.9
Adapted from Fine et al. 2001.
From the table, it can be seen that all three mouth rinses were highly effective at killing planktonic bacteria. Only the essential oils formulation (LISTERINE®) delivered a statistically significant percentage kill versus the control rinse when tested against biofilms.
This study demonstrates the resistance to antimicrobial agents that a biofilm confers, and the difference in biofilm kill rates provided by different commercially available mouth rinses.
References
Fine DH et al. Comparative antimicrobial activities of antiseptic mouthrinses against isogenic planktonic and biofilm forms of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans. J Clin Periodont 2001; 28: 697–700.
We collect your personal information to process your request to create an account for this web site. If you did not give us your personal information we would be unable to open your account. Your personal information will be processed and stored by our contracted service provider who supports this site on our behalf and they are located in the USA.
With your express consent, which you give us by registering and opening an account on our web site, we will send you exclusive offers, product updates and other promotional information about our product range by mail, SMS or email.You may revoke your consent to our use of your personal information at any time by telling us or updating your details on the site. Also, subject to exceptions permitted by applicable law you may request access to, or correction of, your personal information. For further information about how you might revoke your consent, request access to or correction of your personal information, make a privacy enquiry or complaint, or see our full Privacy Policy please<click here>
By pressing “Submit” you expressly consent to : * Receiving marketing communications from us by mail, email or sms; * Your personal information being processed and stored outside your country of residence; and * Your personal information being processed by our contracted service provider.
{* /socialRegistrationForm *}
Thank you for registering!
Register for LISTERINE® PROFESSIONAL
Stay up-to-date on all things LISTERINE®. Register today to receive relevant clinical information for your dental practice.
We collect your personal information to process your request to create an account for this web site. If you did not give us your personal information we would be unable to open your account. Your personal information will be processed and stored by our contracted service provider who supports this site on our behalf and they are located in the USA.
With your express consent, which you give us by registering and opening an account on our web site, we will send you exclusive offers, product updates and other promotional information about our product range by mail, SMS or email.You may revoke your consent to our use of your personal information at any time by telling us or updating your details on the site. Also, subject to exceptions permitted by applicable law you may request access to, or correction of, your personal information. For further information about how you might revoke your consent, request access to or correction of your personal information, make a privacy enquiry or complaint, or see our full Privacy Policy please<click here>
By pressing “Submit” you expressly consent to : * Receiving marketing communications from us by mail, email or sms; * Your personal information being processed and stored outside your country of residence; and * Your personal information being processed by our contracted service provider.
We collect your personal information to process your request to create an account for this web site. If you did not give us your personal information we would be unable to open your account. Your personal information will be processed and stored by our contracted service provider who supports this site on our behalf and they are located in the USA.
With your express consent, which you give us by registering and opening an account on our web site, we will send you exclusive offers, product updates and other promotional information about our product range by mail, SMS or email.You may revoke your consent to our use of your personal information at any time by telling us or updating your details on the site. Also, subject to exceptions permitted by applicable law you may request access to, or correction of, your personal information. For further information about how you might revoke your consent, request access to or correction of your personal information, make a privacy enquiry or complaint, or see our full Privacy Policy please<click here>
By pressing “Submit” you expressly consent to : * Receiving marketing communications from us by mail, email or sms; * Your personal information being processed and stored outside your country of residence; and * Your personal information being processed by our contracted service provider.
Looks like you have an existing account with us. We have made some changes to our site and we need you to create a new password in order to login. Click send to recieve an email with instructions on how to create your new password.
Almost Done!
請在登入之前確認以下的資料。
{* #socialRegistrationForm *} {* socialRegistration_emailAddress *} {* socialRegistration_firstName *} {* socialRegistration_lastName *} {* socialRegistration_password *} {* socialRegistration_passwordConfirm *} {* socialRegistration_gender *} {* birthYear *} {* socialRegistration_addressStreetAddress1 *} {* socialRegistration_addressStreetAddress2 *} {* mobilePhone *} {* haveChildren *} {* customQuestions *}We collect your personal information to process your request to create an account for this web site. If you did not give us your personal information we would be unable to open your account. Your personal information will be processed and stored by our contracted service provider who supports this site on our behalf and they are located in the USA.
With your express consent, which you give us by registering and opening an account on our web site, we will send you exclusive offers, product updates and other promotional information about our product range by mail, SMS or email.You may revoke your consent to our use of your personal information at any time by telling us or updating your details on the site. Also, subject to exceptions permitted by applicable law you may request access to, or correction of, your personal information. For further information about how you might revoke your consent, request access to or correction of your personal information, make a privacy enquiry or complaint, or see our full Privacy Policy please<click here>
By pressing “Submit” you expressly consent to : * Receiving marketing communications from us by mail, email or sms; * Your personal information being processed and stored outside your country of residence; and * Your personal information being processed by our contracted service provider.